Jump to Navigation

St. Louis MO Divorce Law Blog

Hanging on to hurt

ASL PIC.jpgBy Allison Schreiber Lee

Sometimes after divorce I think it's easy to fall back on old emotions. To encounter those who have hurt us or wronged us or made us feel smaller or lesser and to react with bitterness and anger, to lash out and inflict just a little of the pain we feel was inflicted on us. But as I get older and (hopefully) wiser, I think there is one tremendous flaw in that pattern- when we lash out in pain it's because we're still in pain. When we react with anger it's because we still hold that anger inside. When we are bitter towards others outside of ourselves, it's because we feel the bitterness inside our soul, we can still taste it on our tongue. And these painful emotions we carry inside, those feelings that we harbor, cause us just as much pain as what we provide to others. So maybe it's time to tell these feelings that there is no longer safe harbor inside ourselves. Maybe it's time to let go of what doesn't serve us, to end the bitterness and replace it with what replenishes us and fortifies us. To taste the sweetness and the joy instead of those old and tired feelings.

Instead of continuing to mull over the past and how difficult it was, maybe it's time to close that door and seal it with a blessing. To turn away from those in our past, not in fear and not in pain, but in acceptance and resolve. To offer those who hurt us release from the past.  Because in releasing them we release ourselves. In letting go we free ourselves. In saying goodbye we open ourselves up.

It is not easy to do, but when we feel the tension creeping up in our throat or along our shoulders, why don't we instead sigh with relief. That the past is done. That we don't have to carry this burden any longer. That we can nod and smile gently and walk away, with a whisper and a prayer, "I release you." Release that attachment. Release those clenched fists. Release the furrow in your brow. Bow your head, honor your past, say goodbye with a blessing, and in all of that you will move forward to what will hopefully be, a path to a better life.

Disclaimer

Ways To Promote Payment of Medical And Other Child Related Expenses

JCH PIC.jpgBy Jack C. Hauser

All parents can agree upon one thing, children are expensive.   In most cases, children spend time in both parents' homes and each parent incurs out-of-pocket expenses.   In Missouri, a Parenting Plan must be incorporated into a Judgment if custody and/or visitation are at issue.  

In many Parenting Plans, the parties agree that they shall each be responsible for a percentage of any out-of-pocket medical expenses or other child-related expenses.  These expenses are separate and they are not included as part of the monthly child support amount.   Unreimbursed medical expenses can add up if the other parent fails to reimburse the parent who initially paid for the expense.

Some parents are very efficient at exchanging this information and reimbursing the other parent; however, the majority of parents have a difficult time exchanging this information and collecting money owed to them by the other parent.   Many parents either do not submit the bills to the other parent at all or they will save up the bills and submit them to the other parent to pay all at once.    The problem with submitting bills all at once is that the parent who owes the money may not have the ability to pay the amount due immediately.  

The best method to stay on top of expenses is to submit a summary report and attach the supporting documents and send the bills to the other parent bi-weekly or monthly either via mail or e-mail.   By sending reimbursement reports on a regular basis each parent has a better understanding of the expenses of the children. Also, if a parent refuses to pay their court-ordered share, a Motion to Determine Liability and a Motion For Contempt can be filed to enforce the amounts due sooner.  

In many Parenting Plan's, specific provisions are included which require parties to submit unreimbursed medical expense and other agreed upon child-related expenses within a defined time period and requires the other parent to reimburse the other parent for their share of the expense within a defined time period.  In many cases, the time period is thirty days.    It is important to read this clause in the Parenting Plan carefully because if a parent fails to submit the expense within thirty days, they are often barred from seeking reimbursement.

The following is an example of a spreadsheet I have my client's utilize to insure that unreimbursed expenses are being paid pursuant to the terms of the Judgment and Parenting Plan:

No.

Description

Unreimbursed Expenses

Percentage To Be Reimbursed

Amount To Be Reimbursed

1

 

Emergency Room - Visit For Alice

$50.00

50%

$25.00

2

 

Prescription - Co-Pay For Alice

$40.00

50%

$20.00

3

 

Soccer Camp

$200.00

50%

$100.00

4

 

 

 

 

 

5

 

 

 

 

 

TOTAL

 

 

 

$145.00

Each party can tailor their table to meet their specific needs.  The most important thing is to get in the practice of sending the report to the other parent with the back-up information on a regular basis so that there is a clear record of communication and a specific request for re-payment of the expenses.

Good record keeping and regular exchanges of information will promote each parent paying their respective share and will clearly define any disagreements that develop.

Disclaimer

How Will My Spouse Be Notified I Filed For A Divorce?

By Bruce E. Friedman

Clients are frequently concerned about how their spouse will be officially notified of their filing for a divorce.  There are various scenarios.  Under Missouri law, a case is considered to have commenced when the required paperwork (including the Petition for Dissolution of Marriage, sometimes called the Petition or Petition for Dissolution) is filed with the court and a "summons" is issued.  A summons is a special form that accompanies the Petition for Dissolution and is intended to be "served" on the other spouse by a sheriff or privately hired "special process server."   Service of the summons and the Petition  is required in order to "start the clock," for the court's time standards, but this does not always occur.  One common reason for this is because frequently the other spouse has already been told about the upcoming filing and his or her attorney has already made contact with us and it is agreed that upon delivery of the Petition and certain other required paperwork, the other spouse's attorney will file an "entry of appearance," which has the same effect of formal service.

Why do some clients want to avoid formal service of process?  Some fear it will appear too aggressive or will be considered shocking and surprising and want to be able to tell their spouse in advance.  Others do not want to potentially embarrass their spouse at work or have them served in the presence of their children.

In recent years, however, due to advances in electronic notification systems and online case filing information, as well as the publication of filing information in legal newspapers, some attorneys will actually send a letter to your spouse within days of the filing and "solicit" their business, likely before your spouse even knows that something has been filed.  While we do not engage in this practice, it is important that you be aware of the likelihood that your spouse may learn about the case being filed even before they are served with the summons and Petition for Dissolution and possibly even before you have discussed this with your spouse. 

It is important that you discuss with your attorney the nature of any "divorce" discussions that you have had with your spouse and how you want your spouse learn about your decision to divorce and about being notified of the filing of your case.

Disclaimer

The Unexpected and Unplanned-For Consequences of a Divorce

By Alan E. Freed

When you are going through your divorce, the last thing you're likely to think about is how you'll feel when you hear of the death of your former spouse.  In the middle of all of the legal proceedings there's probably at least some part of you that secretly (or maybe not so secretly) would take a certain amount of satisfaction out of dancing on your soon-to-be-ex's grave.  But, when your better self takes hold, which sometimes takes a year or two from the time the judge signs the decree, you usually recognize that your children have the right to have two parents, even if one of them falls far short of the mark.

Eventually, your children will be adults and are likely to have children of their own.  That's when you and your former partner become co-grandparents.  If you've managed to work through your anger you'll be able to share the joy in the delivery room, at the baby naming, at the first birthday party, and at all the other happy events that will follow.  No, you don't need to be best friends, but your kids will be a lot happier if they know that family occasions can be pleasant opportunities to have a good time and maybe even to reminisce a little.

No matter how your post-divorce relationship evolves, you'll never be able to adequately plan for your former spouse's death.  That's when you'll realize that a part of your life is gone forever.  You'll also recognize that your children and grandchildren have suffered a huge loss.  You might even find yourself feeling a certain unexpected sadness at the passing of someone you once cared for and who once cared for you.

It's very easy to get lost in the hundreds of details that bog you down as you go through the seemingly endless divorce process.  Those details often make you spend all of your time focused on your immediate concerns:  How am I going to handle being questioned by my spouse's attorney?  Where will I live and how will I pay my bills when this divorce is over?  What will my children's lives look like after we split into two households? 

Remember, however, that there is life after divorce and that you have more control than you realize over how that life proceeds.  One of your choices will be how you choose to relate to your co-parent--your former spouse.  If you can find a way to make that new relationship work, you will discover a higher level of peace in your life and someday you'll be better able to dry your children's tears as they mourn the loss of their parent.

You Are What You Post - The Duty to Preserve Evidence

By David M. Slaby

Our blog has frequently posted warnings regarding written communications with a spouse, child or other family member, etc. resulting in an exhibit used at trial.  These posts have generally warned against communications  written out of anger or emotion, as they may ultimately be harmful if presented to the judge during a trial.  While words said out of anger or emotion can be potentially damaging, words written or said in jest or for fun may be equally damaging.  With so many people actively involved in social media sites such as Twitter, MySpace and Facebook, or internet dating sites, attorneys frequently request information from these sites be produced through the discovery process of divorce cases or custody disputes.  I advise my clients to be mindful of pictures they post of a night out on the town or other social event, and comments that are posted for their friends, because those postings may ultimately be issues in their cases.  Once litigation is pending, clients are prohibited from trying to "clean up" their social media sites prior to producing that information to the opposing attorney. 

Once a case is filed or a person makes a decision to commence a legal action, it is strictly prohibited that someone intentionally amend or delete content from any web site.  This action is called spoliation of evidence and it can have dire consequences.  In the case of Lester v. Allied Concrete Co., et al., both the plaintiff and his attorney were ordered to pay hundreds of thousands of dollars for attempting to clean up the plaintiff's Facebook and MySpace pages after they received a request for social media content in the discovery phase of a wrongful death lawsuit. 80 Va. Cir. 454 (Va. Cir. 2010).  After it was discovered that both the client and the attorney took active steps to clean up the website to hide it from their opponent, the client was sanctioned $180,000 with allegations of perjury forwarded to the local prosecuting attorney - his attorney was sanctioned $542,000 and was referred to the Virginia State Bar regarding allegations of misconduct!

The best way to keep embarrassing or harmful posts on social media sites from being discovered is to not post them in the first place.  It is important to always be mindful that written communications might become the evidence that loses your case.  The biggest question to ask yourself before you write or post something is: "how would this look if this were used as an exhibit in the trial?"  What you write, type or post should always depend on your answer to this question.

Disclaimer

What is Maintenance and How does it Work?

By Bruce E. Friedman

Frequently, one of the first questions a client may ask is "what is maintenance" and then the next questions, depending on who is doing the asking, are either "will I have to pay it" or "will I get it."  Other questions include "how much will I receive or have to pay," and "for how long."

Maintenance is spousal support and used to be called alimony in earlier times.  There are two tests to determine if someone will receive maintenance. First, they must lack sufficient income producing property to meet their "reasonable needs."  The term "reasonable needs" is a relative term and may be influenced by several factors including, but not limited to, the "standard of living" of the parties.  The law requires an examination of the "reasonable needs" of both parties and the ability to pay of the party from whom maintenance is sought. 

Second, the spouse seeking maintenance must be unable to support himself or herself through "appropriate" employment or be the custodian of a child whose circumstances make it inappropriate for the custodian to work outside the home.

Because there is no chart, graph or table to refer to as to this determination or as to the amount or duration of maintenance, the courts consider various factors, including the length of the marriage and the standard of living of the parties.  However, for the most part, if the Court determines that maintenance is appropriate, the award will likely be modifiable and will have an open ended duration.  The courts usually will not speculate as to when there will no longer be need for maintenance and will place the burden on the paying party to seek a modification in the future if they can demonstrate a substantial and continuing change in circumstances that makes the prior award unreasonable.

In most cases, unless a settlement agreement provides otherwise, the death of either party, or the remarriage of the recipient, automatically terminates maintenance.

Maintenance cases and actions to modify maintenance (to increase, decrease or terminate) are frequently very difficult to resolve, in part due to the lack of any official chart, graph or table that is tied to the duration of the marriage, age, standard of living or other factors. However, courts can, and frequently do, alter the amount, up or down, depending on the evidence of a change.

Lawyers generally base their assessment of these challenging issues on the unique facts of your case, case law involving similar situations and even the tendencies of the Judge that a case is assigned to.

Unlike child support, which has guidelines and a formula for determining amounts and laws that govern the duration, the determination of maintenance lacks these clear guidelines or any clear formula.  So, your lawyer must be familiar with case law concerning awards and modifications, and know the tendencies of the judge, in order to asses this emotional and challenging issue. 

You should discuss these questions with your attorney based on the facts of your situation, not on those of other people you may have heard stories from. 

While these cases can be difficult to resolve, with capable counsel, they are frequently resolved without the need for a trial.
Disclaimer

Hiring the "Mean" Divorce Lawyer

By Alisse C. Camazine

Many people come into my office and ask me if I can be "mean."  This is a difficult question because I would rather answer them and say I am tough, honest and effective.  I ask them what they really mean by "mean"?   Do you want "justice"? It probably doesn't exist within your idea of the word.  Do you want to "win" at all costs?   Do you want to hurt your spouse? If so, you probably need someone else. Do you want to use the law to attain the best possible result for you and your children?  If so, I am your woman.

Divorce is not easy. The court system is not a place to assuage your pain or hurt from a spouse's affair or from years of abuse or neglect. It is best to keep your sights on what you really want to accomplish within the bounds of what the system is set up to provide.

Being tough is one thing. Being mean to your spouse often hurts your case, and it often is unnecessarily expensive. Are you willing to spend more money assuaging your feelings and reduce the pot you might receive to continue your life in order to feel better by being mean? Are you willing to incur the wrath of the court by being difficult for no reason? Being mean may mean to you that you don't let your spouse see the children. Will that hurt your spouse, or your children? Have you thought about whether that will affect your relationship with your children and scar them indefinitely? If you don't have children will it hurt your spouse or backfire against you, and cause your spouse to retaliate?  Being mean may mean that you don't provide support to your spouse. But how will that affect your children, or the division of the marital property? Cutting off money causes unnecessary stress on your children as well as on your spouse, and frequently causes you more money in attorneys' fees.

Disclaimer

Amy Hoch Hogenson awarded Rising Star Award at Women's Justice Awards

Amy Hoch Hogenson was awarded the Rising Star Award by Missouri Lawyers Media at the Women's Justice Awards on April 19, 2012. The Award recognizes women lawyers forty and under or within the first 10 years of practice who have already made a difference in the justice system or the profession and who appear on a path toward even greater accomplishment. The awards reach out to women in various segments of our community, including the bar, the bench, public office, civil service, business, academia, non-profits and the community. Ms. Hogenson is a member of the Firm's Family Law department and is certified to practice throughout Missouri and Illinois.  Her areas of practice include divorce, child custody and paternity matters. She was recognized for her daily practice and for her work with St. Louis County's Domestic Violence Court as a special private prosecutor and with UrbanFUTURE.

Disclaimer

What is a continuance? Why are Family Law cases continued?

By Susan E. Block

Lawyers use a lot of words that are second nature to them, but not to their clients or the public. You might hear counsel say: "Your case has been continued by the Judge." A continuance occurs when a case that has been set for a conference or hearing is moved to a later date.

Before a case can be continued there are procedural steps that must be taken by a lawyer. A written motion requesting a continuance has to be filed with the court and set for hearing according to the Missouri Rules of Civil Procedure. All parties to the case must receive reasonable notice of the hearing and the opportunity to be heard. It is professional courtesy to call opposing counsel to see if they are available on the date you set this motion for hearing.

It is not a testimonial hearing. That is, no witness is required to give testimony under oath for this motion. It is rather a non-testimonial motion made by counsel requesting the continuance and responded to orally by opposing counsel.

Sometimes a continuance will be granted by consent of the parties and approved by the Judge. Cases involving sickness of a party or counsel, a death, or new issues concerning financial matters or marital misconduct that have arisen since the case was previously set are examples of reasons for consent continuances.

The Judge will not necessarily approve a request if the case has been pending for an unreasonable time, usually over a year. You should not presume judicial approval.

The fair administration of justice requires that matters be disposed over by the judicial system promptly. However, there are often good reasons to seek a continuance.

Disclaimer

Do We Need An Egg Donation Agreement?

By Tim Schlesinger

When a couple (sometimes a single person) is unable to have a child because they cannot produce fertile eggs, then that couple may seek an egg donor who will transfer fertile eggs to them.  The couple who intends to have and raise the child is called the "Intended Parents."  The Intended Parent or Parents might find an egg donor through a fertility agency or an egg bank.  Sometimes Intended Parents use relatives or friends as egg donors.  The Intended Parents must also obtain the services of a fertility clinic - this is not to be confused with a fertility agency.  The fertility clinic is the medical facility, staffed with doctors specializing in reproductive medicine, which performs the necessary procedures to fertilize the donor eggs outside the womb and then implant the fertilized eggs in the womb of the Intended Mother. 

In most cases, when Intended Parents use a fertility agency or egg bank, the egg donor is anonymous.  The egg donor will have an agreement with the fertility agency.  The Intended Parents will also have an agreement with the fertility agency.  There will never be any direct contact between the Intended Parents and the anonymous egg donor.  Are any more agreements necessary? 

The simple answer is yes.  It is very important for the Intended Parents to have an agreement with the Egg Donor, even when the donor is anonymous.   The most important purpose of the Egg Donation Agreement is to insure that any children born are the children of the Intended Parents, legally and for all purposes.  There is no law in the State of Missouri defining who the legal parent is of a child born through an egg donation.  The egg donor has a genetic connection to the child and the Intended Mother does not, even though she gives birth to the  child.  Therefore, it is critical to have an agreement between the Intended Parents and the Egg Donor which clearly and unambiguously spells out that the Intended Parents are the only legal parents of the child, and the egg donor is giving up all parental rights.  An additional critical reason to have an agreement is to ensure that the Intended Parents can obtain all the necessary medical and genetic information from the egg donor, so that if medical issues arise, the child can get the best, most informed medical treatment.  Finally, the agreement between the parties is necessary (in the case of the anonymous donor) to protect the continuing anonymity of the parties and, in the case of a known donor, to regulate the relationship between the donor and the child.      

 Most, but not all, fertility agencies require egg donation agreements between anonymous donors and Intended Parents.  Intended Parents need their own independent attorney and the egg donor needs her own Independent attorney. All reputable fertility agencies and fertility clinics require egg donation agreements between known donors and Intended Parents.  The good news for everyone involved is that all parties and attorneys are working toward the same goal--giving the Intended Parents the opportunity to give birth to a healthy child.

Disclaimer